On the Accuracy Versus Transparency Trade-Off of Data-Mining Models for Fast-Response PMU-Based Catastrophe Predictors


In all areas of engineering, modelers are constantly pushing for more accurate models and their goal is generally achieved with increasingly complex, data-mining-based black-box models. On the other hand, model users which include policy makers and systems operators tend to favor transparent, interpretable models not only for predictive decision-making but also for after-the-fact auditing and forensic purposes. In this paper, we investigate this trade-off between the accuracy and the transparency of data-mining-based models in the context of catastrophe predictors for power grid response-based remedial action schemes, at both the protective and operator levels. Wide area severity indices (WASI) are derived from PMU measurements and fed to the corresponding predictors based on data-mining models such as decision trees (DT), random forests (RF), neural networks (NNET), support vector machines (SVM), and fuzzy rule based models (Fuzzy_DT and Fuzzy_ID3). It is observed that while switching from black-box solutions such as NNET, SVM, and RF to transparent fuzzy rule-based predictors, the accuracy deteriorates sharply while transparency and interpretability are improved. Although transparent automation schemes are historically preferred in power system control and operations, we show that, with existing modeling tools, this philosophy fails to achieve the “3-nines” accuracy figures expected from a modern power grid. The transparency and accuracy trade-offs between the developed catastrophe predictors is demonstrated thoroughly on a data base with more than 60 000 instances from a test (10%) and an actual (90%) system combined.

Did you like this research project?

To get this research project Guidelines, Training and Code... Click Here

PROJECT TITLE :Faultprog: Testing the Accuracy of Binary-Level Software Fault Injection - 2018ABSTRACT:Off-The-Shelf (OTS) software parts are the cornerstone of contemporary systems, as well as safety-important ones. However,
PROJECT TITLE :Enhancing Localization Scalability and Accuracy via Opportunistic Sensing - 2018ABSTRACT:Employing a mobile phone for fine-grained indoor localization remains an open drawback. Low-complexity approaches without
PROJECT TITLE :Low Cost and High Accuracy Data Gathering in WSNs with Matrix Completion - 2018ABSTRACT:Matrix completion has emerged very recently and provides a brand new venue for low value knowledge gathering in Wireless Sensor
PROJECT TITLE :Dual-Quality 4:2 Compressors for Utilizing in Dynamic Accuracy Configurable Multipliers - 2017ABSTRACT:In this paper, we propose four four:a pair of compressors, that have the flexibleness of switching between the
PROJECT TITLE : High Accuracy Retinal Layer Segmentation For Optical Coherence Tomography Using Tracking Kernels Based On Gaussian Mixture Model - 2014 ABSTRACT: Ophthalmology needs automated segmentation of retinal layers

Ready to Complete Your Academic MTech Project Work In Affordable Price ?

Project Enquiry